The Ultimate Baby Registry [Cheat Sheet] from Real Moms

Earlier this week, my sweet friend and mother-to-be, Jess asked all of her fellow smother mothers to name their absolute MUST-HAVES for her baby registry. It totally had me reminiscing to myself two years ago when I was pregnant with Beckham. I was totally lost!

Side note: DO NOT jump into a baby registry without doing any research first and certainly don’t step into Babies “R” Us without some type of list first. 

The Ultimate Baby Registry Cheat Sheet 

From mama roos, to receiving blankets to sound machines to nose suckers , I’ve got an elaborate baby registry cheat sheet to get you started on all things baby.

I’ve broken down this cheat sheet into five categories:

  1. Top Baby Registries and Their Benefits: This section will tell you what each baby registry offers to new moms.
  2. Registry Essentials and Big Ticket Items: Remember to register for anything and everything because at the end of your due date, you’ll get 15% off discount from most retailers to use on the remainder of your registry.
  3. Mom approved must-have registry items: These items came straight from the horses mouth. No guess work on specific brands.
  4. Other Mom Favorites: A collection of must-have items from a variety of mothers.
  5. Resource: Lucie’s List, one of my most favorite baby registry resources that you have to check out for guides and recommendations on all things baby.


Baby Registry for new moms

Top Baby Registries and Their Benefits

Target Baby Registry

  • Target offers a FREE New Baby Welcome Kit! Pick up your gift at Guest Services for $50 worth of coupons & handpicked samples. These aren’t just regular samples either–I’m talking Maams pacifiers and Nuby Sippy cups!
  • 15% discount on anything left on your registry after the big day.
  • Returns and Exchanges can be redeemed up to a year after your due date.


  • At home or on the go, manage your Amazon Baby Registry on any device whenever—and wherever—you want.
  • Prime members get up to a 15% Completion Discount on eligible items, compliments of Amazon Family.
  • Prime members with a baby registry are eligible for other rotating limited time offers such as a Welcome Box, free parenting eBook, discounts from Tiny Prints, maternity savings, and more.
  • You have 90 days to return most items purchased from your registry.
  • To make shopping even more convenient, we let customers ship gifts to your chosen Amazon Baby Registry address.
  • An automatically generated Thank You list provides everything you need to send your gift-giver a thank-you note. How great is that!?

Babies “R” Us

  • One-on-one registry consultation.
  • Receive a 15% Completion Discount Certificate, with no exclusions, valid on EVERYTHING remaining on your registry.
  • You have up to 1 year after baby’s expected arrival date to make returns.
  • PRICE MATCH Guarantee.
  • Get free shipping on all online purchases of $29 or more.

buybuy Baby

  • Free Shipping Rewards Program allows you to earn unlimited free standard shipping for your baby’s first year with help from your family & friends.
  • Free Goodie Bag full of great samples and coupons, is our gift to you when you register. It is available for pick-up in-store.
  • Build Your Registry with a Friend: Nobody knows you better than friends and family. Let them help you build your registry with the Ask a Friend and Copy a Friend’s registry tools.
  • Referral Program: Refer someone to buybuy BABY® or Bed Bath & Beyond® and when they create a registry, we’ll reward you with $25 off any in-store purchase of $100 or more.
  • Register in-store to receive complimentary announcement cards to let friends and family know you’re registered at buybuy BABY.
  • Price match is guaranteed.
  • Returns never expire.


Baby Registry Newborn

Register for Everything

From the looks of it, Target, buybuy baby and Babies ‘R Us have some pretty sweet benefits from using their registry service, as does Amazon. One thing to remember: ALL of these baby registries offer 15% off your remaining registry so register for absolutely EVERYTHING. Even if no one buys it, you’ll get a sweet discount regardless.

Baby Registry Essentials

While a baby registry is a great way to get some of the bigger and more expensive items you need, don’t forget that a baby’s seemingly inexpensive day-to-day needs quickly add up.

Some smaller items that you’ll always want on hand for your baby include:

  • Diapers (and lots of ‘em) Register for both newborn and larger sizes
  • Baby wipes (Even more so than diapers!)
  • Baby shampoos, soaps and lotions (I recommend hypoallergenic or scent-less)
  • Breast pump (Should be able to get this from your insurance company for FREE) and breastfeeding supplies
  • Bottles and bottle cleaning supplies (You never know which type of bottle your baby will take to, register for a few different brands if possible)
  • Crib bedding (Skip the bumpers)
  • Burp cloths
  • Nail clippers, thermometer and first aid items

Big Ticket Items (Keep scrolling down for specific brands)

Although I know you’ll prefer to buy nursery furniture and decor in advance so that you can set up the baby’s room early, it’s never a bad idea to register for a crib, changing table or rocking chair if you need help with these purchases.

Other large items for your registry include:

  • Car seat
  • Stroller
  • Baby swing
  • Baby bouncer
  • Playard
  • Bassinet
  • High chair

baby registry mom approved

Mom-Approved MUST-HAVE Items

And now, what you have all came here for, a list of must-haves on your baby registry. I’ve organized these suggestions to help you navigate through the list easier and have also linked them on Amazon. Be sure to price check, they may cost less somewhere else.

All of these suggestions are REAL brands that REAL moms use. I am not being paid to promote these, I am simply suggesting my favorites and what worked for my family. 



Diapers and Wipes

You will be changing your newborn’s diaper roughly 5-8x a day, and about 5-6x a day once they reach 6 months. Your little one will wear diapers morning, afternoon, and night for the next 1-3+ years so registering for diapers and stocking up on as many as possible is a really great idea. Oh and P.S most stores will let you exchange diaper sizes if you get too many of one size.

Receiving Blankets

I recommend purchasing a lot of these. You will need them with a newborn. We used on average 3-5 per day and had to wash them all on a weekly basis. Aim for a minimum of 30.

Baby Monitors

Baby Wearing

Bottles and Feeding

TIP: Remember, babies are picky. You will probably need to try a few different brands before you find which one your baby likes. My baby ended up taking to two different brands: Tommee Tippee and Philips Avent. Both were the “natural” style which is supposed to imitate the shape of a breast.


Sleeping and Lounging

Baby Swings

Baby’s Everyday Essentials

Car Seat and Travel

Other Mom Favorites

Here are more items that other moms suggested as must-haves. There was a TON of feedback on this but I only chose the one’s I really resonated with. Do your own research but use these suggestions as a guideline.

“When my baby was tiny, I loved the sleep sacks! Velcro swaddles are so much easier to figure out and harder for baby to bust out! The Baby Dove line has been our favorite soap/lotion. Dean has a Muslim security blanket that he will not sleep without and I highly recommend something along those lines to teach baby to self soothe. I’m sure I’m forgetting a ton but those are big ones for me! Oh and a white noise machine was a lifesaver.” – Erin

“White noise machine with projection, Nuby wacky teething rings.” -Kelli

“A swing, rocking chair, a boba wrap and a jogging stroller because they are so much easier to push on gravel sand grass then a regular stroller.” -Rachel

“Nose frida, boppy pillow (seriously the best thing to use while feeding!), rock n play sleeper, rocking chair.” -Amanda

“White noise machine, we still use with our daughter and she’s 2, a rock and play for when we were going to be at someone else’s house during nap time, or just so I could move it throughout the house, and a bottle sterilizer. Those were the things I used daily.” -Jessica

“Rock n play, my brest friend nursing pillow, boppy great in bed and on a plane.” -Brittany

“MamaRoo baby swing.” -Sandra

“Nose frida, something to baby wear, rock and play, bags that sterilize the bottle parts in the microwave (medela is the brand), sleep sack, pjs that zip and not button for the middle of the night diaper changes.” -Rachel

“Definitely a Rock N Play, I’ve never heard of a baby not loving them! And we used a Dock-A-Tot for Emma to sleep (safely) in bed with us.” -Katie

“Books-What to expect when you’re expecting & What To Expect the First Year….easy, simple, bang on information about ANYTHING you want or need to know!” -Kim

“Pack and play, rock n play, and a swing -preferably one that plugs in and doesn’t have to have batteries” -Kate

“BOB stroller! Worth every penny!” -Cami

“I second the zip up pajamas, nosefrida (sounds so gross at first but it’s a lifesaver when little ones are sick) and rock and plays are awesome! Also find a really comfy rocker. My son is 20 months and still likes to be rocked to sleep.” -Kristin

“I wish I had a bassinet, we waited almost 3 weeks before we decided to buy one. Make sure you have an infant car seat not just a convertible car seat, Regardless of what others may say about having a convertible seat that saves you money, an infant seat will save your sanity… They are so nice when the baby is sleeping just to take in and out of the car into The store or restaurants. Whether you’re breastfeeding or not I would recommend a Boppy pillow they are nice for tummy time for babies, naps (to wrap around their feet to hold them in place) and to give your arms some relief when you’re holding baby. I would recommend a baby swing or bouncer we have the mamaroo but for the price, you don’t use it very long, my son used it less than 3 months before trying to sit up… get a normal swing. Also if you decide to use cloth diapers instead of disposables let me know I can recommend a ton of tips, tricks and things you’ll need for that.”  -Cherish


Lucie’s List

One of my most FAVORITE websites during my pregnancy was Lucie’s list. This website has absolutely everything you need to know about baby registries. She breaks each registry item up into categories which was oh-so helpful.

  1. Car Seats and Strollers
  2. Carriers
  3. Bouncers and Swings
  4. Bath Stuff
  5. Sleeping
  6. Diapering
  7. Feeding
  8. Clothing
  9. Playing
  10. This and That

My Mommy Needs That

Another favorite mommy blog of mine is They have the best “must-have” lists out there and they even break it down according to your little one’s age! Def worth checking out.

Us Mom’s Stick Together

Registering for your new little bundle of joy is one of the most stressful, yet exciting, times of your pregnancy. Once you’re on your way to decorating the nursery everything kind of hits you and you realize, hey I have a baby on the way! Take your time and like I mentioned above, do your own research. What works for one mama will not work for another.

Be sure to check out more of my blogs featuring helpful advice on breastfeeding, sleeping, and other real mom shit.


Want more mom goodness sent to your inbox? Sign up for my monthly email alerts below:


Author: Smother Mother Kate

Katelyn isn't a regular mom. She's a cool mom and creator of The Smother Mother.

Leave a Reply